Menu of Lena's Pizza, Subs and Wings Westfield NY in Westfield, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Lena's Pizza, Subs and Wings in Westfield, NY, offers a delightful journey into the heart of classic American pizzeria favorites with a touch of genuine local charm. Nestled at 45 E Main St, this spot stands out not only for its inviting atmosphere but for the care and quality baked into every dish.

The Specialty Pizzas are a must-try, especially the New Yorker Large Thin Crust Pizza. True to its name, it delivers a thin, foldable crust topped with provolone cheese and offers ample room for customization through extra toppings. It's a faithful tribute to NYC-style pizza, appreciated particularly by those who favor a crisp yet tender base over the thicker varieties so common elsewhere. The Small 12" White Pizza also deserves praise for its bright garlic and olive oil foundation, accentuated by Italian seasonings and mozzarella, striking a wonderful balance of flavors without being overpowering.

For those craving a burst of freshness, the Veggie Pizza loaded with banana peppers, onions, sweet peppers, mushrooms, and black olives impresses with its vibrant medley. Meanwhile, the Hawaiian Pizza stands out with its sweet and savory blend of pineapple, ham, and bacon, offering sweet relief to traditional pizza expectations.

Besides pizza, Lena’s excels in wings and subs. The Jumbo Chicken Wings are legendary here — juicy, flavorful, and perfectly paired with their homemade blue cheese or ranch, and crunchy carrots on the side. Whether grabbing a 12-piece portion or the massive 48-wing bucket with up to four sauce options, these wings showcase the kitchen's skill in balancing spice, tenderness, and tang.

The Chicken Fingers also shine, served with choice sauces and the same homemade dressings that elevate the finger food experience. It’s hard not to appreciate how tender and well-seasoned these are, making them a perfect complement or satisfying meal on their own.

Lena’s cold subs bring an additional layer of heartiness to the menu. Classics like the Ham Sub, Turkey Bacon Club, and the delightful Joey Sub (ham, salami, pepperoni) come loaded with fresh lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone cheese, oil, and mayo—each bite crisp, balanced, and savory.

What truly elevates the experience at Lena's, beyond the food, is the heartfelt service. Customers frequently praise staff members like Avery, Riley, and Julie for their warmth, professionalism, and dedication. Their attentiveness transforms a meal into an inviting community experience, with personalized touches that complement the menu’s homey appeal.

While minor inconsistencies like crust cutting on the New Yorker pizza have been noted, the team is quick to listen and adapt, showing a commitment to preserving authentic flavors and presentation. This responsiveness, alongside the consistently fresh ingredients and carefully crafted dishes, cements Lena’s as a Westfield gem for pizza lovers and wing enthusiasts alike.

In summary, Lena's Pizza, Subs and Wings offers more than just food; it hands you a slice of tradition, matched with modern care and welcoming service. Whether craving a wood-fired inspired thin crust, crispy jumbo wings, or a hearty cold sub, your order here is made with genuine passion—a quality that keeps locals and visitors returning time and again.